



Durham: The
Dieters Last Resort
A 60 Minutes Special Report
| Sep 19, 2004 7:11 pm US/Eastern |
NEW YORK (CBS) Whether the economy is good or bad, whether
we are at war or peace, there is at least one constant in
American life: fat.
A record 43 million people are now seriously obese in
this country. And while overeating may seem to be an addiction,
so is dieting.
And to confuse things even more, countless studies show
that 95 percent of all dieters eventually re-gain all the
weight they lost.
“Fat City,” as Correspondent Morley Safer
first reported in Jan. 2002, may be their last resort.
While there may be nothing funny about fat, the dieters
call Fat City the "Lourdes of Lard.” But the
city is better known as Durham, N.C.
Durham used to be the capital of Big Tobacco, but as tobacco
moved to cheaper, greener pastures, the weight-loss industry
moved in.
The industry produces a financial gain of about $80 million
a year, making Durham the quiet diet capital of the world.
There are three major clinics, not pampering fat farms,
but medically supervised, no-nonsense establishments with
very strict regimens.
Thousands come annually, and they lose about 100 tons
a year – about the same weight as the fully loaded
planes they ride in on.
“Durham is Ground Zero for weight loss. If you can’t
lose weight in Durham, you can’t lose weight,” says
author Jean Renfro, who came here 13 years ago and lost
100 pounds. She was so taken by the power of Durham's diet
culture, and the way it lives off the fat of the land,
that she decided to stay and build a career.
She’s now an anthropologist who specializes in fat.
Why fat? “Well, No. 1, I am fat,” says Renfro. “And
I thought I would study my own culture. Why go somewhere
else when I can do it right here at home?”
Renfro has written a book called "Fat Like Us," which
gives some idea how desperate people can be. They can lay
out anywhere between $3,000 and $8,000 a month to take
off the pounds.
“People sell everything to get here. They sell their
cars, their homes, everything they own,” says Renfro. “Cash
in any savings just for the opportunity to lose weight
in Durham.”
It started in the '40s, when Dr. Walter Kempner at Duke
University proclaimed that a strict diet of fruit and rice
not only kept diabetes and high blood pressure under control,
but led to enormous weight loss.
The rice diet put Durham on the map, and celebrities who
were had experienced so much weight gain - such as Shelley
Winters, Buddy Hackett, James Coco, Col. Sanders - all
headed south.
“I would watch some ex-fattie on TV talk about how
they lost all their weight in Durham,” says Renfro. “And
I remember, as a small child, eating potato chips and watching
that and thinking, ‘I will be that.’ I will
be in Durham one day.”
And she was. She spent months on the rice diet. Over the
years, two more serious diet programs were established
in Durham. At the Duke Diet & Fitness Center, Pennsylvania
high school football coach Michael Mischler, and Charlie
Beech, who came from Venezuela, had both reached critical
mass.
“I remember when I hit 300, it was, 'Wow -- 300
pounds -- only the fattest people on earth are 300 pounds.'
Well, now I'm 400,” says Mischler.
“It's just really poor eating habits. I mean, you’re
going home, wife's trying to help you out by cooking a
healthy meal. I call her up and I say, ‘What are
we having for dinner?’ "Well, you know, I'm
having some chicken and rice." I'm like, ‘All
right, well, I'll stop at McDonald's on the way home and
get a value meal.’”
That little pre-dinner snack had about 1,800 calories.
At Duke, Mischler is allowed only 1,650 calories for the
entire day. They're also taking classes on how to shop
in the supermarket, and they have to undergo a form of
dietary torture: eating just one slice of pizza.
“They teach you to eat the first part slowly, and
then the second half, they ask you to cram it down your
face,” says Mischler. “When I had my second
half, it kind of reminded me of the way I used to eat.”
There's no secret potion, just a simple rule: eat less,
move more. The payoff? In eight weeks, Beech lost 46 pounds.
And in four weeks, Mischler lost 29.
Both feel it’s just a beginning, but they say they
couldn’t have done it on their own.
“If it was that easy, more than half of America
wouldn't be obese at this point in time,” says Mischler. “I
mean, it's not that easy. And I needed to get away from
my environment.”
That's the most common theme you hear. And retired Chicago
lawyer Evette Zells says the only place where she can lose
weight, and keep it off, is in Durham.
“I’m building my life around that fact I bought
a small house here, and in order to control it for the
rest of my life, I will have to spend probably several
months, or more, here every year,” says Zells.
Zells has been working out at the Duke Center for Living,
and she’s lost 140 pounds. This time, she’s
a veteran at taking it off and putting it back, because
she’s been doing it for 40 years.
She admits there is something almost addictive about this
place. “When you’re here, you’re away
from everything at home. You’re away from your family.
You’re away from the pressures,” says Zells. “There’s
no one here to tell me that I can’t be in the gym
for three hours every day. There’s no one here telling
me, ‘Let’s go out and have pizza.’”
Dieters say the Durham experience is addictive, because
of the sense of community a fat person feels here.
Renfro says it's like a religious experience because there
is nothing like weight loss to transform a fat person's
life: “You really come alive here. You really become
yourself here. Where at home, you’re somebody’s
wife, you’re somebody’s mother, somebody’s
daughter. But in Durham, you’re whatever you’re
going to be.”
“Is it like a religion in that sense, that you want
to be near the cathedral, you want to be near the Lourdes,” asks
Safer.
“Yes, of course. And it has to be. To be really
effective in weight loss, you have to incorporate it as
a religion,” says Renfro.
She says religious references abound in the weight loss
culture. The local strip of fast food restaurants is called "Sin
City," and before they start the program, many indulge
in "The Last Supper."
Marianne Dorfman remembers her last supper well, and she
and her friend, Gloria Sayles, say Sin City is a constant
temptation. Has either one of them ever slipped away for
a quiet burger?
“No. Fortunately, we went out as a group and we
were there for each other,” says Sayles. “I
won’t say we weren’t tempted. As a matter of
fact, everywhere, cheesecake, you know, it was calling
us. ...But when we were weak, then fortunately the other
person was strong.”
The common goal of becoming "un-fat" does form
strong bonds -- they eat, live and work together, and together,
they learn to understand their weakness.
“One of the workshops told me that I have to learn
to love this overeater,” says Dorfman. “Well,
I said, ‘Love it? I wanna kill it, here's the gun.
I want to kill it.’”
But there is no magic bullet, says Dr. Gerard Musante,
director of the Structure House Diet Center. “People
want quick fixes. And perhaps it's our society has gotten
to feel that things can be done easily,” says Musante. “Life
isn't like that. This is a long-term problem.”
Across town at the Duke Rice Diet, some people are battling
matters of life and death. Marilyn Brill, whose weight
brought on congestive heart failure, says she tried everything
before coming to Durham.
“I've been to Dr. Atkins himself, and Dr. Lynn,
and my husband thinks Weight Watchers is charity that we
contribute to every year,” says Brill. “But
besides that, I came here -- I was really sick. I literally
couldn't walk from the door to a table.”
Kevin Brown also checked himself into Rice, because at
only 31, he feared his obesity might soon cost him his
life. Just 13 years ago, after graduating from high school,
he was a trim 240 pounds.
“When I first came to the Rice Diet two weeks ago,
I weighed 604 pounds,” says Brown. “I’ve
lost 43 pounds so far. I want to get down to healthy, probably
around 230 to 250 would be healthy for me, because I’m
a big guy.”
He thinks this may be possible, because there are success
stories from the Duke Rice Diet that have done just that.
Success stories like John Illg, an Iowa farmer who came
to Rice a year ago, weighing 651 pounds. Since then, he’s
lost 365 pounds – a pound a day.
Now weighing in at 282, he says he's ready to face the
world: “When I saw Kevin Walk in the door, I saw
myself a year ago. That's what I saw.”
“I'm hoping I see myself in a year looking like
John,” says Brown, who will need to exercise, eat
and get weighed, along with other Ricers.
They’ll also have to eat the same bland fruit and
grain, day after day. But just around the corner, Sin City
still beckons.
“If you're window shopping, the temptation's there,” says
Brown. “But, you know, at 604 pounds, I realize that
that’s life-threatening.”
“I am going to have it all off. I'm gonna be gorgeous
as I used to be and very strong,” says Brill. “And
if Oprah's ready to give up her show, maybe I'll be over
there. But I'll keep my weight off.”
The ability to laugh at oneself is another common theme
in Durham.
“If we lived in Japan, we'd be sex symbols,” says
Beech.
“I use humor as a defense mechanism where I'm trying
to say, ‘Listen, I know you know I'm fat, but that's
OK, and I'm gonna joke about it,” says Mischler.
Joking aside, how are the dieters 60 Minutes met doing
now – nearly three years later? The results are mixed.
Mike Mischler initially lost more than 100 pounds, put
it all back on, gave up on dieting and opted for surgery
to reduce his stomach size. He has now lost over 100 pounds
once again.
Charlie Beech succeeded at first, but then put it all
back on and also opted for surgery. Marilyn Brill kept
to her regimen and has lost 95 pounds. John Illg has lost
another 75 pounds, for a total of 440 pounds.
And Kevin Brown? Sad to say he has given up on all programs.
He now weighs 605 pounds.
|